Oct 6, 2026
0
min. Reading Time

I Met Lucy Calkins at The Reading League. I Still Have Questions.

I Met Lucy Calkins at The Reading League. I Still Have Questions.

I Met Lucy Calkins at The Reading League. I Still Have Questions.

Missy Purcell

Advocacy Champion

Last week, I ran into Lucy Calkins at The Reading League Conference in Chicago, and I have been thinking about it ever since.

If you don’t know my story, it was featured in Emily Hanford’s Sold a Story. I was the teacher, and the mom, who had been trained in the same practices that later failed my own child.

Lucy Calkins was a huge part of my preservice teacher training at the University of Georgia. I still have my copy of The Art of Teaching Writing. Later, my district introduced me to Fountas and Pinnell’s Guided Reading. Balanced literacy wasn’t something on the edges of my career. It was how I’d been taught to think about reading.

I believed it, and I taught it faithfully.

Then I had a child with dyslexia.

If you’ve been through that, you know it changes how you see everything. I watched the school that was supposed to teach my son to read hold on to methods that weren’t working for him. I was told those methods were appropriate for kids with dyslexia. I still have the emails saying they wouldn’t focus on sounding out words. I still get emotional about that.

I now know what he needed, and I know what the research says. I also know how deeply our schools are built around this approach. So standing in the same room with Lucy Calkins, at a conference about the science of reading, was complicated.

To be clear, I don’t have a problem with her learning. Everyone should be learning. If you find out that what you believed, taught, and sold doesn’t line up with evidence, I want you in that room. But learning brings a responsibility to act on what you learned.

We talked briefly. She mentioned how hard it is for teachers to take in all this information and then go back to their districts and figure out how to use it.

I kept thinking: Teachers have been trying.

The science didn’t suddenly appear when it became popular to attend a reading conference. Researchers, teachers, parents, advocates, and people with dyslexia have been raising the alarm for years. Some of us begged. Some of us were dismissed. Teachers were told to follow the curriculum anyway. Parents were told to trust the experts. Kids paid the price, especially kids with dyslexia.

So my question isn’t whether she belongs in the room. It’s what she does after she leaves it.

I have said for years that we can’t keep repairing the Balanced Literacy Fortress. When the foundation is wrong, new windows and fresh paint don’t fix it. You take it down and rebuild it on what the evidence tells us about how children learn to read.

That is what I am wondering:

Will Lucy Calkins take apart what she built? Or will she renovate it?

Those are not the same thing.

The newest version of Units of Study is being marketed as including science-of-reading principles, foundational skills, and knowledge building. Adding good practices to an old program raises a question: when do we admit that some of the original instructional methods were wrong? Not outdated. Not in need of refinement. Wrong.

If they were wrong, someone has to account for what that meant for kids.

I haven’t seen that reckoning yet. I haven’t heard the public acknowledgment that I think families and teachers are owed. I haven’t heard much about the children who struggled unnecessarily while adults were taught to encourage them to use strategies other than actually reading the words on the page. I especially haven’t heard enough about children with dyslexia.

Those children belong at the center of this conversation. My son does. So do the thousands of parents who asked for evidence-based instruction and were ignored, and the teachers now realizing their training didn’t prepare them to teach children how to read. Most of all, I think about the kids who decided somewhere along the way that they were the problem.

So yes, Lucy, keep learning. Go to the sessions. Listen to the researchers. Talk to teachers. Talk to parents. And please talk to adults and kids with dyslexia who lived through classrooms shaped by these practices.

Then tell us what you learned. Tell us what you got wrong, and what you’d say to the teachers you trained and the parents whose children couldn’t read. Tell the kids who needed explicit instruction in the code, and didn’t get it, what you’d say to them now.

Then tell us what you’re going to do about it.

One more thing needs to be said out loud. If I am a superintendent today with limited resources and an enormous responsibility to get literacy instruction right, and I have a choice between investing in well-vetted, evidence-aligned materials with strong evidence behind them or investing again in materials from someone whose previous approach helped lead us down the wrong road, why would I choose the latter?

That isn’t about revenge. It isn’t about refusing to let people change. It’s about accountability.

Changing your thinking is good. Changing your materials is better. But when your work shaped literacy instruction in thousands of schools and influenced generations of teachers, I think change also requires publicly reckoning with what came before.

Lucy Calkins built an empire. I want to know what she’s willing to dismantle.

Maybe showing up at The Reading League is part of that journey. I hope it is. But attending a conference isn’t the reckoning, and neither is a new edition of Units of Study.

The reckoning begins when we are willing to say clearly what went wrong, who was harmed, and what we’ll do differently now.

I believe people can change, and I think there has to be room for that. But I also believe that when your influence helped shape how an entire generation of teachers was taught to teach reading, learning something new isn’t the end of the story.

It’s where the responsibility begins.

Join my newsletter!

Stay informed with the latest tips, resources, and advocacy updates straight to your inbox.

Newsletter Review

The tips and updates from the newsletter have been incredibly helpful in our advocacy journey.

Lena Boone

Mother & Teacher

© 2024 Miss Purcell All rights reserved | Site Built by Hacks4Marketing LLC

Join my newsletter!

Stay informed with the latest tips, resources, and advocacy updates straight to your inbox.

Newsletter Review

The tips and updates from the newsletter have been incredibly helpful in our advocacy journey.

Lena Boone

Mother & Teacher

© 2023 Miss Purcell | All rights reserved
Site Built by Hacks4Marketing LLC

Join my newsletter!

Stay informed with the latest tips, resources, and advocacy updates straight to your inbox.

Newsletter Review

The tips and updates from the newsletter have been incredibly helpful in our advocacy journey.

Lena Boone

Mother & Teacher

© 2024 Miss Purcell All rights reserved | Site Built by Hacks4Marketing LLC